I've loved Charlotte Perkins Gilman's “The Yellow Wallpaper” ever since I read it in
middle school and reading it for COM 3 made me pretty happy. Strangely, though, it was so hard for me to come up with
another work I can relate it to. Pop culture seemed to be the easiest way to
go, but the light bulb above my head just wouldn't turn on. The next morning, I woke up remembering a movie I watched two years ago, Secret Window, the movie adaptation to Stephen King's novel of the same name. It was perfect. And it stars Jack Sparrow Johnny Depp.
Besides, who isn't crazy for doesn't like or know Mr. Depp?
Not only did I discover how wonderfully the movie relates to "The Yellow Wallpaper," I've also discovered that this
<-- motivational picture is for real. All of the ideas came pouring out... Unfortunately, I have a word limit.
Joking aside now. (Sort of...)
I'm just going to go with what I remember about the movie, so I apologize for some inaccuracy. I have a fine memory (with the help of limited videos online and wiki). Although, I would like to see the movie again to get a feel of my post, but Netflix has all of Depp's movies except this one and, as a college student, watching a movie = 2 hours of lost, precious time = body becomes lazy/tired = realizing that there's more work to do = freaking out over lost time and the work not started. Well... for me, at least.
So, here it goes.
Secret Window is about an author, Mort Rainey, who becomes traumatized after he discovers his wife, who is insane for cheating on Johnny, has been having an affair with another man. To avoid facing the reality that she wants to divorce him, he isolates himself in his cabin far away from the city.
John Shooter intrudes in Mort's only refuge and accuses him of plagiarism. In denial, Mort tells Shooter that he has a few screws loose and shoves him away. However, Mort lets curiosity get the best of him. After reading Shooter's work, Mort realizes how impossibly similar it is to his own writing. The next day, Shooter approaches Mort and offers him a deal. If Mort can prove, within three days, that his work existed before Shooter's, then they will move on with their lives.
This deal should have been easy and Mort would've returned to living forever alone in his cabin. But, it wasn't and that's okay because we get to have more fun and adventure when our hero's life becomes downward spiral into despair, right?
So, Mort gets a call from his estranged wife telling him that their house burned to the ground destroying the copy of his book, his proof. (Let's skip some murder scenes). Time is running out. The following day, Mort's agent mails a copy of a magazine with his story. Mort realizes the pages of his story have been torn off the magazine. He first assumes Shooter did it. But, wait... Shooter doesn't have access to this magazine. The package was sealed until Mort opened it. There's no way Shooter could be the culprit. Unless...
GASP!
This is what Mort's "inner voices" were trying to tell him.
There are now two Johnny Depps Morts!
Mort accepts that Shooter was just a figment of his own imagination. He then beats his wife to death, decapitates her lover, and buries them underneath his corn field.
In the end, Mort gets away with it. For now...
Anyways, this suspenseful movie relates to Gilman's work through the contrasting themes of isolation and freedom.
Isolation: In "The Yellow Wallpaper," the narrator and her husband, John, retreat to their summer vacation home. John believes that isolation will cure her depression, but it doesn't. Actually, it makes things crappier than they already are. Similarly, in Secret Window, Mort attempts to heal his broken heart, but, eventually, it turns into a vengeful one. The isolation gave the narrator and Mort more time to realize all that is wrong in their lives.
Freedom: The narrator treats her isolation as a prison. The yellow wallpaper becomes her only friend. Eventually, she begins to see patterns on the wallpaper that take a shape of a woman, who the narrator identifies with. Therefore, in the end, the wallpaper woman is the freed version of the narrator like how Shooter is a freed version of Mort.
The narrator and Mort had to lose themselves, to free themselves. Freaky, right?
The similarities are crazy. I can only say that John was lucky to have only passed out unlike what Mort did to his wife's lover.
I really liked your post, I'll probably try and watch that movie now :)
ReplyDeleteI suppose the only difference between the two (Mort and the narrator of "the yellow wallpaper") is that in the yellow wallpaper we really felt no ill will towards john, it seems like she just wanted him to love her like she to him.
Anyway, I should watch the movie to see how we go from realizing shooter is a imaginary friend to killing people.
Well there goes my productiveness for the night, time to watch a Johnny Depp movie!
ReplyDeleteIts interesting how humans tend to think isolating themselves and running away from problems is the easy solution. The husband in the Yellow Wallpaper seems to think that he can eliminate a serious mental illness by physically separating her from the problem, the same as Johnny seems to do in this novel. However, both these works probably aim to provide the lesson that to truly solve problems we must face them head on.
Dude, with Johnny Depp, you could totally kiss productiveness goodbye! haha!
DeleteAnd, yeah, running away is totally pointless. Problems must be faced head on or else we'll find ourselves even more helpless than we did before we ran away.
You make the movie and the story actually work and seem similar. Time to watch it online now. Lol.
ReplyDeleteWallpaper probably didn't get as vengeful as the Depp movie, but hey. Nice comparison :) Wallpaper is just as creepy since it shows how crazy the wife is.
I like how you compared the deranged murderer to the characters in the Yellow Wallpaper because I would have never otherwise seen the connection. I think you did well with remembering the movie and were very accurate, although I've never seen it. I like the technique with the pictures interspersed throughout because it made the reading go by a lot faster in a good way.
ReplyDeleteI really like the connection you made with the two pieces. John had basically taken his wife on a vacation to cure her illness and Mort isolated himself to escape the reality that his wife is going to file a divorce. Its funny how people think running away from the problem is the "cure." The only difference I see is that John is trying to help his wife but Mort's wife is wanting a divorce.
ReplyDeleteThanks everyone for the reply. I'm glad you all liked it and saw the connection. :)
ReplyDelete